SLOW COOKER SWEET POTATO CASSEROLE. Sweet, creamy brown sugar sweet potatoes topped with a velvety brown sugar sauce and crunchy pecans! This side dish is made even EASIER by using the slow cooker, plus there’s directions for the oven also! The perfect dish for Fall and all Holidays!

This sweet potato casserole recipe is so easy and simple to make. Best of all it uses FRESH sweet potatoes, but if you need to save some time you can make this dish with canned yams instead. Another bonus is the fact that this casserole can be made in the slow cooker (affiliate link)!

But again, I share directions on making this in the oven also if that’s an easier method for you. Holiday dishes need to be all about ease. It’s tough making so many dishes to be ready at the same time. So knowing a variety of methods is the best way to go!

How do you make sweet potato casserole?

This sweet potato recipe starts with fresh sweet potatoes. Peel them and chop them up into 1 inch cubes. Cook them in the slow cooker to soften, cook them on the stove, or if all else fails and you need a casserole quick, you can use a canned version.

My favorite is the slow cooker, because I can toss them in with about 1 cup of water, set it to high heat for 3 hours and let them cook to soften.

Once the sweet potatoes are cooked and softened. We add in the other ingredients. Milk and butter make the casserole creamy and rich. Feel free to use half and half or cream if you want to amp it up a bit. I use whole milk. And the eggs add an almost pie-like custard texture to the sweet potatoes.

Other ingredients include: Brown sugar, you can use a dark brown for a more intense molasses experience or light brown for a less pronounced flavor. Then add in some cinnamon and nutmeg. Feel free to add some cloves, and even a pinch of ground ginger if you want. I love to let the sweet potato shine though. Too many spices can take away.

Mash it all together and smooth out the top.

All ingredients mashed together for a sweet potato casserole.

Smoothed out top of sweet potato casserole to add the brown sugar pecan topping.

Sweet Potato Casserole Topping:

The topping is kind of why I love sweet potato casserole so much. The typical toppings for sweet potatoes are marshmallow OR pecans. I’m more of a pecan type girl myself. Especially when those pecans are drenched in a butter, brown sugar sauce and baked on top of creamy sweet potatoes. But you can very easily make this sweet potato casserole without pecans.

If you would prefer to make a marshmallow sweet potato casserole: you can leave off the pecan topping. Bake the casserole as directed in the recipe, then once it’s done, turn the heat off, top with marshmallows, put the lid on and let the remaining heat melt the marshmallows and serve once they are melted.

To make the Brown Sugar Pecan Topping: Pour the sauce over the top of the sweet potatoes and we will let the whole thing cook in the slow cooker, or bake in the oven, for about another 30 minutes.

Then we’re left with the ULTIMATE sweet potato casserole. This casserole is smooth and creamy with the crunch of the pecans on top. Spiced with just a hint of cinnamon. This casserole will be the first dish finished come Thanksgiving, or whatever meal you decide to make this to go with!

More Holiday Side Dishes:

Mashed Potato Casserole

Autumn Apple Salad

Corn Casserole

WANT TO TRY THIS SWEET POTATO CASSEROLE??

PIN IT to your SIDE DISH or THANKSGIVING board TO SAVE FOR LATER!

FIND ME ON PINTEREST FOR MORE GREAT RECIPES!